Haut Commissaire à l'énergie atomique
PDF file of the speech
Mister Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen,
It’s a great pleasure and honor for me to welcome you all to Nice for the 2007 International Conference
on Nuclear Data for Science and Technology. Indeed, I am very pleased to see such a large attendance
to this important scientific meeting and I wish to congratulate the organizing committee warmly for such
a success. This series of conferences aims at bringing together scientists and engineers that are involved
in the production or use of nuclear data. I am quite confident that such a conference helps efficiently at
promoting the long-term joint efforts that are definitely needed to produce and to use broadly nuclear data
always more precise and reliable, more complete and more consistent. The renewal of interest on nuclear
data, as well as on nuclear basic science, which I and many others are pleased to contemplate today is, to
my opinion, the consequence of a better perception of the assets of nuclear energy by public opinion and
decision makers and of the increasing confidence in the safety of the nuclear technologies, knowing well
that we ought to remain vigilant on this point.
A foreseen growth of the demand of energy and more specifically of electricity all over the world
within the present century, whatever the energy savings we could afford, surely will lead to a large scale
development of nuclear energy worldwide. Today, commercial nuclear power reactors are providing safe,
abundant, competitive and permanent energy without emission of carbon di-oxide and other greenhouse
or polluting gases. Nevertheless, the populations expect big efforts to manage nuclear wastes in a more
sustainable and fully secure way. The general purpose is to minimize substantially waste amounts and
reduce significantly proliferation risks by recycling used nuclear fuels and reprocessing spent fuel, which
requires the development of new techniques.
Whatever the technological progresses, during the major part of the 21st century, the nuclear energy will
be mainly produced from thermal nuclear reactors. However major international cooperation programs
are focusing on medium- and long-term research. Their objective is the optimization of the use of natural
uranium’s energy content in fast reactors and the preparation of their deployment as soon as their economic
competitivity is established. For example France is convinced that the best way to proceed is to follow a
continuous improvement passing from the graphite-gas first generation of reactor to the fourth fast neutron
reactor generation. We are presently moving to the third one with the EPR in Flamanville expected to be
operative in 2012 while the fourth generation will be in the forties.
As to the world ITER project which will be the step further, three key areas justify the on-going completion
of many fusion data files: tritium breeding in the blanket, shielding of the magnet region and neutron
induced radiation damage in the first wall.
France is fully concerned by the progress in nuclear technologies. I’ll limit myself to four examples:
as I told a few minutes ago, EDF, the French electricity producer has been authorized a few months ago
to launch the construction of the EPR, the first of a new generation of light water reactors. In addition
to safety improvements and reduction of waste, increasing the burn-up rate of UO2 and MOX fuels and
optimizing plutonium consumption are key objectives of optimization of EPR.
The CEA is in charge to design a fast reactor prototype working in closed cycle and satisfying sustainable
developments of the fourth generation of nuclear reactors. The French parliament voted, in 2006, a
law specifying the management of waste. A part of this program is related to research on the partitioning
and transmutation of long-lived radio nuclides in order to reduce the mass and the toxicity of the waste.
The success of this research program relies much on the fulfillment of a large number of nuclear data
requests on minor actinides produced during irradiation and still present long after cooling and storage
periods. In addition, alpha emission from actinide decay, ternary fission and (n,α) reactions have to be
implemented. They are responsible of helium production, during and after irradiation, which enhances the
pin inner pressure up to critical values especially in MOX fuels.
About fusion, I am pleased to stress the French contribution to the ITER program and happy with the
choice of Cadarache to host the largest Tokomak ever built in the word.
The range of nuclear data required for the optimal operation of existing reactors or in the design of
more competitive ones, while keeping the same safety requirement, is still large.
In order to take advantage of the accuracy of the numerical simulations offered by the availibilty of
super computers and the quality of neutronics codes coupled with thermo-hydraulics codes, we need more
and more complete nuclear data files with reduced margins of uncertainty. Several sessions will be devoted
during this week to the numerous nuclear data activities.
The success of the conference will be associated with the progress in two major items: first, in sensitivity
calculations with evaluated files including covariance matrices which provide the essential information
for reliable uncertainty estimates and, second, in the benchmarks for fission application such as those
carried out in international collaboration on the three French critical facilities EOLE,MINERVE and MASURCA.
The quality of the integral measurements on these facilities not only provides confirmation of
calculation methods using differential cross section data, but, also, tends to consider them as a source of
Some sessions will deal with theoretical methods, notably those involving microscopic or semi-microscopic
models dedicated to the calculation of cross sections in various energy ranges. These theoretical
efforts ought to be strongly supported in order to achieve a set of coherent data using only nuclear reactions
models, especially for actinide nuclei where the competition of the fission processmust be treated in details
and consistently with other exit channels.
Neutron measurements in the thermal and resonance range along with their analyses will be presented
in several oral and poster sessions.In the near future, SPIRAL 2 will extend to higher energy the range
covered, in Europe, by GELINA and n-TOF where many of those measurements have been done. At
intermediate energy, the heavy-ion facility FAIR, to be built in GSI at Darmstadt, will allow spallation
studies in connection with the ADS program.
Looking at the full program of this busy week, it appears that other areas are also concerned with nuclear
data such as space, medicine, astrophysics to mention only a few of them. All of these presentations are
shared in several sessions and will be heard with interest.
All the efforts on reliable nuclear data would be useless without the role of the NEA data bank in
charge of the Joint Evaluated Fission and Fusion project. It’s why this conference is also organized under
the auspices of the OECD Nuclear Energy Agency. I am happy to address my kind regards to Dr. Akira
Hasegawa, the Head of the NEA Data Bank who opens this session with me.
I wish a full success to the 2007 International Conference on nuclear Data for Science and Technology
and I hope there will be time for all of you to enjoy, in addition, the delights of the French Riviera.
Thank you for your attention.
OECD/NEA Data Bank Head
PDF file of the speech
Thank you Mr. Chairman, Good Morning Ladies and Gentlemen,
On behalf of the NEA Director-General, and in the name of the OECD Nuclear Energy Agency, it is a
great pleasure for me to welcome all of you to the International Conference on Nuclear Data for Science
and Technology. The NEA is pleased to be cooperating with the French Commissariat à l’Énergie Atomique
in organizing this latest and most prestigious international conference on Nuclear Data, following
previous conferences successfully held in Santa Fe, Tsukuba and Trieste in the last ten years. This conference
has a long and glorious history of more than 40 years, starting with the first Washington conference
in 1966. Since the very beginning until the present day, NEA has been very closely involved.
My first words are ones of gratitude to CEA, not only for their kind offer and the efficient organization
of this conference but also for their reiterated support of the OECD Nuclear Energy Agency activities in
The success of an international conference depends very much on the dedication and work of its international
advisory and programme committees. I therefore would like to thank both Committees for their
work in the preparation and selection of the papers for this conference.
To end this part of acknowledgements, I thank all of you who have travelled from many countries,
nearly 45 in all, in order to exchange the latest information with your invited and contributed papers and
new topics for discussions. These constitute the essential ingredient, not only for the conference but for
the progress in this field. Again, thank you very much, ladies and gentlemen, for your interest in this
conference and also in the activities of the NEA.
As researchers, I dare say that you enjoy the privileged situation of being able to gauge the direct impact
of your work on the lives of your fellow citizens and you also bear the associated responsibility of working
under the constant call from society to ensure sustainability in its broadest sense. The field of nuclear data
is very broad and it involves interdisciplinary studies extending over many areas of physics, engineering
and chemistry. It deals, on the one hand, with fundamental aspects of nuclear interactions and, on the
other, with applications in various fields. This conference is application-oriented but due consideration is
given to the fundamental aspects relevant to the basic understanding of the data.
At the NEA, the international community joins efforts in the Working Party on International nuclear
data Evaluation Co-operation, WPEC as we call it, promoting the exchange of information on nuclear
data evaluations, associated measurements, nuclear model calculations and related topics, and it provides
a framework for co-operative activities between the participating nuclear data evaluation projects, not
only in NEA, which only accounts for 28 countries, but also in the rest of the world through the joint
cooperation of IAEA.
For the evaluation and measurements of nuclear data, international cooperation is inevitable. The number
of nuclides to be considered exceeds 1000, required only for the nuclear energy applications today.
If we consider very short life nuclides, which are attracting more and more attention for the edge-cutting
researchers and astro-physical researchers, it diverges into an extremely large number; and each nuclide
induces so many reactions. Each reaction spans so wide a range of energies, in log scales more than 14,
i.e., from sub milli eV to the GeV range. And nuclear data are measured in so many areas of the world.
Considering the limitations of human resources, coordination and cooperation is inevitable in the field of
nuclear data; this is why such dense cooperation has evolved.
Thus nuclear data centers in the world, such as the NEA Data Bank, have been set-up and have been
operating until today. With the close cooperation between data users in the application fields in research
as well as in industry, measurements, evaluations and formatting to the evaluated libraries are made and,
as the final product, ENDF/B-VII, JEFF-3.1, JENDL-3.3, BROND, CENDL, FENDL, these libraries have
been produced and supplied to the public reflecting the needs in each regions.
Extending our focus to the future, we can see the big projects are waiting for us. For examples, GENIV;
the fourth generation of nuclear power plants, or GNEP: the Global Nuclear Energy Partnership, ITER
in fusion, for those, there are no confirmed mock-ups yet in the world; thus nuclear tools, i.e., nuclear data
and computer codes, are the essential ones, so yearly efforts has been made up to today to sharpen the
edge as possible as we can. Nowadays, it is essential to cope with both aspects of safety and economy for
nuclear energy applications. At present we are always questioned by ordinary users about the accuracy of
nuclear data and their reliability quantitatively. We cannot say we have achieved our goal yet but we are
approaching it steadily, as you will see in this conference.
Before you engage in your specific discussions, I would like to mention some general considerations
about the current world energy scene and the role that nuclear is playing and is expected to play in the
not-so-distant future. I am doing so not just to provide you with some recent figures on general indicators
but in the hope to underline to what extent your efficient and dedicated work in the field of nuclear data
can actually contribute to shape the years to come.
Energy policies are driven by economic, social and environmental factors. In OECD, Sustainable Development
is a key issue for the organization. According to the Bruntland Report, the concept of sustainable
development is the process of balancing the need of humans for economic and social development with the
need to protect the natural and built environment so that these needs can be met not only in the present, but
also in the indefinite future. Therefore, economic, social and environmental, these three items are mutually
interconnected as in a complex system.
I would like to take a moment to reflect with you on each item. For the first item, Economics, competitiveness
of various electricity generation options varies from country to country. For nuclear, capital
investments represent 60% of the total cost against 40% for coal and 17% for gas. However, another cost
component, that of fuel, puts nuclear in a more comfortable position at 15 In the first place, about where to
invest research and development activities in the nuclear field: indeed, lower capital investments brought
about by new technologies, new optimized procedures, control systems and innovative materials will always
be welcome. But the message also comes with a cautionary tone: any proposed development needs
to be carefully examined from a cost perspective if it is to be successfully implemented.
With the current LWR deployment and assuming a once-through cycle, identified uranium resources
will last for more than 85 years (or 270 years if we add the inferred and other more prognosticated resources).
Fast neutron reactors and closed cycles can drastically change the picture and multiply by a
factor of 30 the duration of the identified resources. You can find further information on this topic of quantifying
uranium resources in the recently appeared 2006 NEA/IAEA Red Book on uranium resources.
Our current world situation presentsmany challenges, and society and governments are actively seeking
responses to them. When we speak about nuclear energy, you immediately guessed, society is rightly
addressing us, experts, questions on radioactive waste disposal and proliferation issues.
Nuclear data needs for advanced reactors systems and advanced nuclear fuel cycles will be one of the
main subjects of discussion during this meeting and has been a recent topic also within NEA working
groups, which is a good thermometer, I like to think, indicating the attention paid to the subject in our
societies. Concern about nuclear proliferation issues is also a consideration of this conference in line with
the topics on safeguards and security issues.
In order to complete this morning’s tour of the sustainable development issues, I would need to reflect
for a moment on the purely environmental component of the technologies emerging from the advanced
reactor concepts under study on forums like GEN-IV. Greenhouse emissions are an environmental issue.
Many positive things can and have been said about nuclear in this context. But environmental concerns
have other facets and, as in the case of economics, the message is to continue to develop technologies with
high inherent levels of safety. I also feel this message is well understood by industry and consequently the
nuclear data community as well that has incorporated it as one of its driving principles.
After these few snapshots trying to show how your current efforts in the nuclear data field can and
need be integrated in a sustainable development perspective, I would like to express, as a representative
of the OECD Nuclear Energy Agency, my satisfaction with your large presence here today as experts
from all over the world. Thank you very much for traveling to Nice for this conference. The success of
this series of conferences, clearly appreciated by the increasing number of participants at each edition, I
interpret as a good example of our sound record in terms of workingmethods and structure for international
collaboration. In 2004, the NEA Data Bank celebrated the 40th anniversary of its activities in the field of
distribution of large collections of experimental and evaluated nuclear data as well as computer codes; in
2008, next year, the NEA will celebrate the 50th anniversary of a rich international collaboration.
On behalf of the NEA Director General, Mr. Echávarri, I wish you a very successful and fruitful
Thank you for your attention.